
Most Renew firms price their clients for the following year in November or December.
Most of the pain has subsided from the fall deadlines, and the uncertainty of who is coming back next year is on the firm’s mind. The question is, are you in right mindset to price your clients for next year?
We know you are in the right pricing mindset on March 25th. On March 25th you have been grinding, you are tired and in the back of your mind there is a finish line called April 15th. Whenever you price, pretend it’s March 25th (when firms do their best pricing), when you’re at capacity and aren’t willing to take the work on unless you get your value (and you also don’t take on clients who aren’t a long-term fit).
Note to self: Pricing is an attitude and it’s a combination of art (emotion) and science (numbers).
Colin and I are walking a firm through this right now. Their average hourly charge rate (AHCR) is $146. Reminder: average hourly charge rate is revenue divided by billable hours. This can be an estimate. Let’s face it, most partners are terrible at keeping time. This number is an important number, as most firms aim at nothing and hit it with amazing accuracy.
If you are still pricing in arrears, writing off old WIP and chasing A/R, shoot us a text at the number below.
Back to our discussion. The Renew Model Firm target is $250 per hour. When we ran their client list, 167 clients sat below minimum price. That’s 167 decisions to make before tax season, and the window to make them with intention is about to close.
Start with a floor: for example, $1,500 for individuals and $5,000 for businesses.
How do you determine your minimum? Take a firm with $1M revenue, $400K labor, $200K fixed costs and 350 client groups. Most partners would say break-even is ($400K + $200K) ÷ 350 = $1,714. It isn’t. Labor scales with the work, so it comes out through the gross margin (60% here). Fixed costs don’t, so we spread them evenly. That gives $200K ÷ 350 ÷ 0.6 = $952.
We straight-line fixed costs deliberately. A $500 client drinks the same cup of coffee as a $50K client. Most firms have no idea what it costs just to have a client on the books.
A minimum isn’t a judgment about any one client. It’s a statement about your business model. Below that line and the work costs you more than it pays. Clients above the minimum aren’t exempt either. If their AHCR is under target, they get an increase too.
Pricing has two sides. Firm profit is price less cost. Customer profit is value less price. Most firms only think about the second one. Price to win for the firm, not just to keep the client.
Packages, to reduce free work and make the intangible tangible
For individual clients, we built three packages: Essentials, Planning and Year-Round.
Each one says what’s included, when the client’s information is due and when payment (all by ACH) happens, which is upfront. That makes the invisible work visible. It also helps end or dramatically reduce scope creep, because "can you just look at this" now has a home. It’s either in the package or it’s a conversation about moving up a level. Also, by getting clients to pay upfront they have "skin in the game." Eg reduce the chasing of information and not getting paid to do so.
BTW, there is no such thing as a quick answer. There might be such a thing as a quick question. Put another way, just because you can answer something in 15 minutes doesn’t mean it’s only worth 15 minutes of time. Most of you have worked for decades in accounting. How can you reduce decades of work by charging by the hour? Your value can’t be captured in an hourly rate.
One rule: when a client moves into a package, their price goes up, not down.
Download the Packaged Pricing Example
The partner’s response was honest: "I get the concept, but upfront pricing depends on the client."
The package depends on the client, do not price the service.
Make sure you understand the client’s "pains and gains" and sell to those attributes. This is the art piece. Renew has a pricing approach and calculator to help.
When pricing depends on the client, it really depends on the partner’s comfort level that day. That’s how you end up with 167 clients priced on the same package with a different price. This takes time and a mindset shift and is the most important thing you do in your firm. Every client gets an upfront price. Judgment still matters.
Most firms don’t block enough time to price their services. Do this now.
Send letters in early December.
Waiting until January feels kinder, but it isn’t. In January, your letter lands in the same pile as the 1099s and gets read halfway through tax season. In December, clients have time to decide, you have time to answer questions, and you start tax season knowing who’s in, at what price and paid upfront. You don’t want to be determining capacity in February.
Across all 2026 Renew submissions to our annual benchmark study, the average price increase was 11.5%, and 6.2% of clients left as a result (mostly Insanity Zone clients). That’s more revenue from less work, and a better client mix.
Once your pricing is where the model needs it, don’t let it drift. Another pricing mistake firms make is NOT raising their prices every year. Most of your costs go up every year so should your prices. A 5–10% increase every year keeps you there.
If you want to improve your pricing and achieve a better tax season, shoot us a text or schedule a call.
Book a 15-minute Discovery Call
Download the Packaged Pricing Example
Webinar: How Seth Fink fixed his tax season and grew from $950K to $2.9M
Seth’s team threatened to quit after tax season. Now, his firm is on track for $2.9M from half the clients, and he averaged 59 hours a week last tax season (down from 108).
On Wednesday December 2 at 4pm ET, we’re hosting a 30-minute interview with Seth Fink. It covers how Seth analyzed his business model, got focused on the right clients with packaged pricing, and fixed his tax season. Please join us.
Text us at 317.496.2192
if you want to talk it through.